High Speed Bulk Bag Filling - Preweighing Design Considerations

In the article "High Speed Bulk Bag Filling - Preweighing", preweigh bulk bag filling systems, capable of achieving filling rates up to 40 bulk bags per hour, were described:

"Pre-weighing refers to weighing the payload of product to be placed in a bulk bag in a separate bin or hopper above the bulk bag filling machine.

Doing so eliminates the time required to precisely weigh the product as it flows into the bulk bag on the filling machine. Rather, the pre-weighed 'shot' can be dropped into the bulk bag as quickly as it can be made to flow through the pre-weigh hopper outlet."

In this article critical design considerations will be discussed.

Product Conveying Balance

A preweigh bulk bagging system capable of filling 40 bulk bag per hour must be 'fed' by the upstream production process and the system that conveys product to the bagging location, at the same rate - product in must equal product out.

This can be accomplished in two ways.

Often, the production line will continuously convey product to a large silo (50+ tons capacity).  The preweigh bulk bagging system is located underneath the silo and bulk bagging occurs either continuously, if production can keep up with the bulk bagging rate, or periodically when production has filled the silo to an appropriate level.

A less common arrangement is where the production line can continuously match the bagging rate and product is continuously conveyed to the bagging line where it is continuously filled into bulk bags.

Weighing

Designing the weighing sub-system is the most challenging aspect of implementing a preweigh bulk bagging system.

As was shown in the previous article, a 40 bag per hour system has a total cycle time of 90 seconds.  Of that, 15 seconds is allocated to emptying the preweigh hopper (the vessel wherein the product shot is weighed) into the bulk bag.  From the preweigh hopper's perspective, the remainder of the cycle time - 75 seconds - can be used to weigh the next shot.

Assuming a typical dribble feed duration of 15 seconds,  the fast fill portion of the weighing cycle is 60 seconds.

Typically, 50 - 100 lb of the total shot weight is dribble filled.  That means that, in the case of a 2,000 lb bag, 1,950 lb of product must be metered into the preweigh hopper in 60 seconds.  This equates to a very high instantaneous flow rate of approximately 117,000 lb/hr.

Two key factors must be considered to maintain accurate and consistent weighments:

1. Flow control.  The device used to meter the product into the preweigh hopper must be properly selected.
2. Flow rate.  The rate at which the product flows into the preweigh hopper must be consistent from bag to bag. 

There are a number of ways to design such a weighing system according to the desired weighing accuracy and capital budget.

Note that preweigh systems can be designed to consistently maintain accuracy of +/- 2 lb.

Bag Stability

The faster bulk bags are filled the less time is available for densification.  Further, bag stability becomes more of a concern as the bulk bag filling rate increases. 

Applications with bagging rates over 20 per hour must be carefully assessed to determine what amount of densification is required to produce safe and stable packages.

As the bagging rate approaches 25 bulk bags per hour and beyond, stability and densification become a major concern with almost any product - particularly if stacking the bulk bags is a requirement.

In a preweigh system capable of filling 40 bulk bags per hour, the filling machine must be carefully designed to ensure the filled bags are stable and safe.

In the next article we will look at when a preweigh bulk bagging system should be used.

High Speed Bulk Bag Filling - Preweighing

Maximum bulk bagging rates are achieved when using a pre-weigh system. 

Pre-weighing refers to weighing the payload of product to be placed in a bulk bag in a separate bin or hopper above the bulk bag filling machine. 

Doing so eliminates the time required to precisely weigh the product as it flows into the bulk bag on the filling machine.  Rather, the pre-weighed 'shot' can be dropped into the bulk bag as quickly as it can be made to flow through the pre-weigh hopper outlet.

So, instead of a fast feed and dribble feed cycle with weighing conducted on the filler that, at its fastest consumes 50-55 seconds, a pre-weigh system can fill a bulk bag in approximately 15 seconds.

Removing 40 seconds from the bulk bag filling cycle time dramatically increases the bulk bagging rate.

Bulk Bag Filler vs. Pre-weighing

Let's examine the numbers in more detail:

Task	Filler Weighing (seconds)	Pre-Weigh (seconds)
Rig bulk bag	30	30
Tare	5	5
Fast Fill	40	15
Dribble Fill	15	NA
Final densification	15	25
Remove filled bag	15	15
	120 seconds	90 seconds

Note that the Filler Weighing cycle time is only 120 seconds - that equates to 30 bags per hour.

That is a very high rate and is possible with many products using high speed bulk bag filling equipment.  However, as can be seen, adding a pre-weigh system to this type of bulk bag filler increases the bagging rate considerably.

A 90 second cycle time means that a properly designed pre-weigh system is capable of filling 40 bulk bags per hour!

Also note that the final densification time has been increased.  This compensates somewhat for the reduced amount of total densification time compared to the Filler Weighing cycle where the bag would be densified for most of the Fast Fill task.

In our next article we will dive into the design issues that must be considered to properly implement a bulk bag pre-weigh system.

Bulk Bag Flexibility

Last week I had dialogue with a potential customer who was stumped with a bulk bag problem.  The solution had nothing to do with bulk bag handling equipment; rather it had everything to do with the flexibility of bulk bags themselves.

This customer was faced with having to fill bulk bags with a sludge like material that contained over 20% moisture.  Needless to say, it easily bridged and ratholed.

Specifically, the customer's system was being designed to mechanically convey the product to a small surge hopper, which would in turn empty into a bulk bag.

The customer was searching for a way to ensure that the product would flow easily from the surge hopper into the bulk bag.  However, they had been unable to find a suitable solution to getting the sludge through the bulk bag inlet spout sized at the typical 14" diameter.

The answer required a paradigm shift.  That was: bulk bags do not have to have a spouted top.

As can be seen in the following diagram, bulk bags can be manufactured with many different top and bottom configurations.

In the case of this application the solution was to use the 'skirt top' design shown above - also commonly known as a duffle top bag.

This allowed the customer to design the surge hopper with an outlet large enough to prevent bridging and ratholing while still being able to get the product into the bag. 

All they had to do was open the duffle top to completely expose the inside of the bulk bag and let the sludge fall from the large opening in the bottom of the surge hopper.

Because the product was so heavily moisture laden dusting was not an issue. Therefore, there was no need to have the bulk bag inlet sealed to the surge hopper outlet.

Plus, the duffle top allows the bag top to be tied and closed securely preventing comtamination of the product and spills.

The customer was able to simply, easily and inexpensively solve their problem once they learned that - true to their name - Flexible Intermediate Bulk Containers or bulk bags can be designed to suit almost any bulk solids handling task - flexible indeed!

Bulk Bag Weighing Accuracy - 4 Critical Success Factors

Bulk bags can and should be weighed to within +/- 2 to 5 lbs accuracy - at any bagging rate with any product.

Following are the four critical factors that must be considered to achieve acceptable bulk bag weighing accuracy:

1. Consistent product flow.  Any batch weighing application's accuracy increases as the consistency of the product flow rate increases.  This refers to the flow rate during a batch and from batch to batch.  Bulk bag fillers typically have a weighing algorithm that includes an "in-flight offsett" program that 'learns' when to stop product flow ahead of reaching the weight target to compensate for product that is falling between the metering device and the bulk bag.  The more consistent the flow the better the algorithm is able to fine tune the system.
2. Metering device. Weighing accuracy is critically dependent on how well suited the metering device is to the application.  A simple, two position gate valve may provide adequate accuracy when filling bulk bags with reasonably low bulk density product at a slow rate.  However, when filling a high bulk density product at a high rate a conveyor/feeder may be required to achieve the desired accuracy.  Note that the ultimate accuracy of a positive displacement type metering device (e.g. screw conveyor, screw feeder, rotary airlock, etc.) is limited to +/- the weight of product in one flight or pocket.  Therefore, high bagging rate applications require great care in selecting the best metering system: a conveyor sized to provide a high flow rate necessary to achieve the desired bagging rate may not be able to produce adequate weighing accuracy because it is too large  In that case, a different metering device, a second dribble feed device or a surge hopper with fast acting gate valve may be required.
3. Dead load.  The weight that the weighing system sees before product is added to the bulk bag is called the dead load.  Gross weighing systems - those that weigh the entire bulk bag filler along with the product in the bag - can see a dead load of up to 2,000+ lb depending on the filler and its configuration.  Bulk baggers that use hang weighing see a dead load equal to a few hundred pounds.  This means the hang weighing filler can use smaller load cells or that the portion of the load cell span taken up by the dead load is much smaller.  Either way, higher weighing resolution and more accurate weighing is the result.
4. Weighing system minutiae.  When filling bulk bags the specific type of load cell, controller/PLC resolution and scan time and the like are really not significant factors in achieving weighing accuracy.  In my experience any weight controller and PLC implimentation has more than enough resolution to achieve the desired bulk bag weighing accuracy.

Training - Critical To Bulk Bag Discharging Success

One of the most overlooked keys to bulk bag discharging success is training.  This post reviews how properly trained operators facilitate a safer, cleaner and more productive bulk bag discharging operation.

Key bulk bag discharging tasks that require specific operator training:

1. Preparing the bulk bag for unloading.  In most cases this is a simple task requiring only the attachment of the bulk bag lifting loops to the lifting frame used to place the bag in the discharger.  However, when certain types of liners are involved the operator must know how to safely use the bulk bag unloader's liner tensioner to hold or wind up the liner during discharge thus preventing it from becoming entangled in downstream equipment.
2. Using bulk bag discharging equipment.  The most common cause of bulk bag discharging problems is misuse of bulk bag discharging equipment.  At best, not following the manufacturer's operating instructions results in poor ingredient yield, unecessary operator involvement to initiate or maintain ingredient flow and/or dusting.  The worst scenario is when an operator's lack of knowledge creates a safety hazard.  This is most often seen when operators reach under an unsupported, suspended bulk bag to untie the outlet and initiate flow.
   
3. Removing the empty bulk bag.  A bulk bag that has just been unloaded is full of dust laden air.  How the operator removes the bag can either maintain a dust free environment or create a dust clogged mess that in some circumstances results in a safety hazard.
4. Disposing of the empty bulk bag.  Even if a bulk bag is removed from the discharging equipment and transported to the point of disposal properly, problems can arise if an operator folds the bulk bag or otherwise expels the dust laden air in an uncontrolled manner - causing a dust clogged mess.

Of course, the first step in sucessfully training operators is to develop well thought out Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs).  With precisely defined operating objectives, tasks and expectations training success is greatly enhanced.

Handling Bulk Bag Liners During Discharge

Often bulk bags require inner liners, usually made of polyethylene, to protect the ingredient.  Care must be taken when discharging lined bulk bags to prevent entanglement with downstream equipment and to ensure 100% product yield.

Liners come in many forms: loose tubular, loose fitted, sewn-in, glued-in.

Loose means that the liner is not in any way attached to the outer bulk bag.

Tubular means that the liner is basically a cylinder of polyethylene film that is stuffed in the bag.

Form fit means that the liner is constructured with sides, top and bottom and usually inlet and outlet spouts - it looks just like a bulk bag only it is made from polyethylene film.

Loose Bulk Bag Liners

Whether tubular or form fit, a loose liner requires some sort of physical means to prevent it from discharging with the ingredient and becoming entangled in downstream equipment.  A device called a liner tensioner is typically attached to the bulk bag lifting frame or rigging frame to prevent this from happening.

Liner tensioners vary in their operation, but the most basic simply hold the liner in place preventing it from moving out of the bag.  More sophisticated tensioners wind up a portion or all of the liner as it is emptied.

Before the bulk bag is lifted into the discharger the inlet spout of the bag is untied to expose the tied liner inlet.  The liner neck is then wound onto the liner tensioner spool piece, which is then either fixed in place or rotated to take up the slack in the liner by activating its actuator (typically pnemuatic).

Attached Liners

Even though liners that are attached to the outer bulk bag are designed not to discharge with the ingredient, it sometimes happens anyway.  Often a basic liner tensioner that holds the liner in place is used to guarantee that the liner cannot move.

Liner Tensioner Conisderations

1. Liners 'grow'. Loose liners and liners attached to the top of the outer bulk bag will extend out of the bulk bag outlet spout during ingredient discharge.  Particularly in the case of loose tubular liners, care must be taken to ensure that even if a liner tensioner is used, the liner cannot extend or grow out of the outlet spout enough to foul downstream equipment.
2. Too much liner winding.  If a liner tensioner that winds continuously is used typically the liner outlet is clamped to prevent it from winding all the way up onto the spool piece.  If this is allowed to happen, and the ingredient is at all dusty, dust will be sprayed into the surrounding area when the empty liner is rapidly wound up through the empty bulk bag and then spins around the spool piece.
3. Liner length.  When a liner tensioner is used the liner inlet must be long enough to reach the tensioner spool piece.
4. Ensuring 100% yield.  A liner tensioner that winds up a loose liner - partially or completely - can assist with ensuring that all of the ingredient is dishcarged from the liner.  The act of winding up the liner helps to get the last pounds of ingredient out of the bag.

Handling Hazardous Ingredients In Bulk Bags

Increasingly, bulk bags are used to ship 'hazardous' dry bulk solid materials.  This post investigates what you need to know to handle them.  Note that we will address the topic of how bulk bag manufacturers make bags to meet relevant regulations related to robustness and package integrity in a subsequent post.

First, let's discuss what hazardous means.  The United Nations defines hazardous goods as follows:  "Definition of 'dangerous goods' covers articles or materials capable of posing significant risk to people, health, property, or environment when transported in quantity."

That's a broad definition, but for the purpose of this discussion we'll focus on three potential hazards that can arise during bulk bag handling:

1. Static discharge.  Bulk solids that within a bulk bag may generate enough static charge to iginite flammable vapors, gases or dust.
2. Explosive dust.  Bulk solids whose dust, if allowed to accumulate in a high enough concentration, may explode if exposed to a suitable ignition source.
3. Health hazard.  Bulk solids that present a health hazard to humans via direct contact.

Dissipate Static

There are two ways to mitigate the risk of static discharge: bag and equipment design.

Of the four types of bulk bag (Type A, B, C and D), typically only types C and D are used to prevent static discharge leading to explosions. 

Type C bulk bags feature conductive fabric or conductive threads or filaments woven into non-conductive fabric.  The key factor is that Type C bags must have a grounding point to which all fabric, threads or filaments are connected.  The grounding point must then be connected to an external ground point duing filling and discharging of the bulk bag.

Type D bulk bags are constructed from fabric that allows static charge to be dissipated without being connected to ground.  The advantage of Type D bags is that operators are not required to making a ground connection with the bag prior to filling and unloading - a task that can be forgotten sometimes resulting in disaster.

Equipment used in situations where static discharge could ignite flamable substances must, as a minimum, have ground lugs.  Depending on the Area Classification electrical components may have to be explosion rated.

Contain Dust

If the product you are filling or discharging can cause an explosion if a high enough concentration of dust is exposed to an ignition source, dust containment is critical.

Bulk bag fillers must have 'twin-tube' fill heads and provide a tight seal with the bulk bag inlet spout.  The outer tube of the fill head must then be connected to dust collection system so that dust laden air that is displaced during the filling process is safely extracted.

Bulk bag dischargers must have dust containment features suitable for the hazard level.  There are different levels of dust containment available (discussed in another blog post).

All equipment must feature electric components rated for the Area Classification.

Isolate Human Contact

Bulk solids that are health hazards include various refined metals that are carcinogens, chemical compounds that cause respiratory problems and so on.  When dealing with these products maximum dust containment is required.

Specialized bulk bag discharging equipment is available for this application.  It is critical that such equipment contain dust at the following critical steps in the bulk bag unloading process:

• Initial onset of product discharge.  The point in time when product begins to flow from the bulk bag can create a large amount of dust.
• Throughout bulk bag emptying.  Of course, dust must be contained as the bulk bag is emptying.
  
• End of discharge. Near the end of the discharge cycle the bulk bag will loose its shape.  Equipment must be designed to maintain dust containment integrity at this crucial stage.
  
• Bag removal.  Removing the empty bulk bag - still full of dust laden air - must be done safely without exposing operators to dust.

Further, bulk bags must be designed to prevent the escape of product particles during handling - otherwise referred to as 'sifting'.  Coated or lined bags can be specifically designed to suit the product and the hazard.

This is only a brief overview of handling hazardous goods in bulk bags.  Users and bulk bag and equipment manufacturers must coordinate closely to ensure safety.

Bulk Bag Dusting - What Causes It?

A common rap against bulk bags is that unloading them can be a dusty mess.  In the first of a series of posts related to bulk bag discharging and dusting, let's examine what causes dust emissions.

1. Bulk bag design.  Unless a bulk bag has been specifically designed to contain the fines present in a given product, particles can sift through the bag fabric.  This looks like smoke escaping from the bag as it is being handled and emptied.  Depending on the amount of fines present in the product, the particle size and its shape, coated fabric may be all that is required to contain the dust.  However, in some cases polyethylene liners are required to prevent product sifting. 
2. Onset of product flow.  The point in time when the operator releases the outlet spout tie and product begins to flow can be a significant contributor to dust emissions.  If the product is flowable, when the outlet spout is released a down rush of product can occur - if the down rush occurs quickly this happens while the access door to your bulk bag unloader is still open.  The rapid drop of product causes an updraft of dust laden air that must be extracted properly or it will result in a cloud of dust being emitted into the atmosphere.  Look closely at how your bulk bag discharging equipment is designed to prevent this.
3. Product flow.  Bulk bag discharging equipment must provide suitable dust containment while the product is moving out of the bulk bag.  While this seems obvious, make sure your equipment can't loose its ability to extract dust during the discharge cycle due to the bag moving as it empties thereby altering the integrity of the 'seal' that the equipment relies on to maintain proper dust containment.
4. End of the discharge cycle.  As the final pounds of product empty from a bulk bag it may cause the discharging equipment's dust containment/extraction features to loose their ability to control dust.  This can result from the bag breaking its seal with the equipment as it looses its shape near the end of the discharging cycle.
5. Empty bulk bag removal.  Dusting can still occur even when the bag is 'empty'.  When a dusty product has been discharged from the bulk bag, the bulk bag is still full of dust laden air.  If the bag is removed from the discharger without re-tying its outlet spout the dust laden air will exit the bag in transit from the discharger and spread thorughout the immediate plant area.  Even if the outlet spout is retied prior to removing the empty bag, care must be taken in how it is handled when it reaches the disposal area - a bulk bag can't be folded or compressed without doing something with the dust laden air it contains.  Determine the best Standard Operating Procedure for your situation and ensure that your bulk bag unloading equipment supports it.  It may be necessary to use purpose-built bulk bag folders to make this step of the process dust free.

As can be seen dust containment and extraction must occur at multiple points in the bulk bag discharging cycle to maintain a clean and safe plant environment.  Careful equipment design and well thought out operating procedures are both required to optimize your bulk bag unloading operation.

5 Ways to Reduce Bulk Bag Packaging Cost

In previous posts we have discussed reducing shipping costs and the benefits of replacing or eliminating pallets.

In this week's post let's discuss all of the ways that the cost of bulk bag packaging can be reduced.

1. Reduce bulk bag size.  Reducing the height of a bulk bag by 10% decreases its price by roughly 5%.  Maximum densification, for example using the cone table densification system, can almost always decrease bag height by 10% - sometimes by as much as 40% or more.
2. Eliminate baffles.  If your bulk bags have internal baffles and they are being used to enhance stability, it is highly likely you can eliminate them by using a densification system designed for maximum results.  Getting rid of baffles can save as much as $5 per bag.
3. Use coated bulk bags.  If you use liners in your bulk bags you may be able to eliminate them and use coated bulk bags instead.  See the blog post "Bulk Bag Liners - When To Use Them... or Not!" for an excellent review on when to use liners and when not to.  Switching from a liner to a coated bulk bag can save as much as $2 -$3 per bag.
4. Replace wooden pallets with plastic channels.  Using plastic pallet replacement channels can reduce direct packaging cost and logistics related costs too.  See the blog post "Eliminate Wood Pallets - Ship Bulk Bags Without Wood Pallets" for details.
5. Eliminate wooden pallets.  Properly designed and filled bulk bags can be handled only by using their lifting loops thereby eliminating pallets - and their cost - completely.  See the blog post "Pallet Free Bulk Bag Handling" for details.

As you can see from there are numerous ways to significantly reduce the cost of your bulk bag packaging.

Reduce Bulk Bag Shipping Cost

How can bulk bag users reduce shipping costs?

The bulk density of your product determines the opportunity for shipping cost savings.

If your product is heavy enough to weigh-out a shipping container/trailer then, as we have seen in the last two posts, replacing wood pallets with a plastic channel replacement system or simply eliminating bottom support altogether can significantly reduce shipping costs.  Reducing the weight of packaging per shipment means you can replace the weight reduction with product thereby shipping out more product per container and reducing shipping cost per pound.

However, if your product's bulk density is such that you can't weigh-out a container/trailer there is an additional step you can take to minimize shipping cost.

Bulk Bag Densification Increases Payload

Light products such as wood flour, fluff carbon black, fumed silica and the like react favorably to certain types of densification.  This means that the payload of a given size bulk bag can be increased.  Increasing the bulk bag payload increases the amount of product that be shipped per container thereby reducing shipping cost per pound.

Low bulk density bulk solids tend to trap air between their particles. Depending on the particle shape it can be very difficult to remove the air while the bulk bag is being filled. Bulk bag filler densification systems are designed to remove the trapped air thereby densifying the product.

Some densification systems are more effective than others. Carefully matching the method of densification with the product characteristics can result in a significant improvement in packed bulk density thereby increasing payload.

Bulk Bag Densification Reduces Shipping Cost

As a starting point it is reasonable to assume that a densification system capable of maximum compaction should be able to increase payload weight by a minimum of 10%.

Control and Metering's experience is that payload increases of 20-30% are often achievable and in some cases as much as 40%+ more weight can put in a bulk bag that has been previously filled without densification or with ineffective densification systems.